The Machine in the Garden: Technology and the Pastoral Ideal in America
| Not what you're looking for? Try smart custom search: |
Customer Review
Men Become Tools of Their Tools
Marx's book is roughly 50 years old now, but it still sparkles with insight into the myth and symbol discourse surrounding America's fulfillment of the 18th century idea of the "Garden of the World," a new Eden that would redeem mankind. Starting with "The Tempest" as reflective of the West's view of the geographic discovery of "primitive" and "unspoiled" lands, and moving through Hawthorne, Emerson, Thoreau, Melville, Twain, to Fitzgerald "The Great Gatsby" as an exemplification of how the simple"pastoralism" of the Enlightenment (based on the Virgillian pastoral form), Marx shows how the American artists and writers slowly came to grips with the penetration of the machine into the garden. He talks about the idea of the "middle landscape" a notion poised halfway between primitivism and progressivism, about the apparent perversity of "lazy" early settlers who, in the view of some commentators like Jefferson, never cultivated their own gardens, unlike the English aristocracy. The...
Top to learn more
The Conflict between Pastoralism and Industrialization
In writing this review I am attempting not to duplicate the excellent review by panopticonman below. Thus, I would refer all readers of this review to that review.Marx's thesis, roughly stated, is that: Americans applied idea's developed about landscape in the old world to the landscape they discovered in the new world. In doing so, the landscape became a "repository of value" (value meaning economic, spiritual, etc.). The main idea about the landscape that travelled with them from Europe was the idea of "pastoralism".Pastorialism, roughly expressed, represents the yearning by civilised man to occupy the space in between "art" and "nature". Marx does an excellent job of explaining the pre-modern understanding of "art" (which is different then our modern understanding of the word). Marx also distinguishes the a "simple" conception of pastoralism with a "complex" conception. Using the writings of...
Top to learn more
I can relate to this book
The pastoral image is alive and well, certainly in my mind anyway!As an airline pilot observing the land below I often mused, sometimes in conversation with my fellow crewmembers, what it would be like to fly over the landscape as it existed in an earlier time. Of course, I would still want to be comfortably ensconced in my aluminum cocoon, able to zip thither and yon for whatever my allotted time. Today Hawthorne's peace in "Sleepy Hollow" is more likely to be disrupted by the "long shriek, harsh, above all other harshness...[that] the space of a mile cannot mollify it into harmony" of a jet engine than the whistle of a locomotive.Leo Marx very capably traces the origin of the literary ideal of the "garden" and pinpoints its contradictory meanings through the literary creations of some of America's greatest writers. At its core is the contrast between two worlds, that of rural peace and simplicity or urban sophistication and power. The shriek of the locomotive...
Top to learn more
Product Description
For over four decades, Leo Marx's work has focused on the relationship between technology and culture in 19th- and 20th-century America. His research helped to define--and continues to give depth to--the area of American studies concerned with the links between scientific and technological advances, and the way society and culture both determine these links. The Machine in the Garden fully examines the difference between the "pastoral" and "progressive" ideals which characterized early 19th-century American culture, and which ultimately evolved into the basis for much of the environmental and nuclear debates of contemporary society.
This new edition is appearing in celebration of the 35th anniversary of Marx's classic text. It features a new afterword by the author on the process of writing this pioneering book, a work that all but founded the discipline now called American Studies. Top to learn more







Intriguing look into the structure of the Great Gatsby